Earlier this month, Intel announced their new 11th Gen Intel C or e desktop process or s (code-named "Rocket Lake"). These new process or s are marketed as having substantially better per-c or e perf or mance compared to their previous 10th Gen C or e models, but the top-end model (the C or e i9 11900K) has two fewer c or es than the previous generation which may hamper perf or mance in some applications.
The improved IPC (Instructions Per Clock) perf or mance of these new CPUs should make them significantly faster f or lightly threaded applications like Photoshop and After Effects in particular, but the lower maximum c or e count may become an issue in many other w or kloads. To see how these new CPUs do in a range of other real-w or ld scenarios, we have reviews looking at a number of applications across video and photo editing, game development, photogrammetry, and m or e. While this post includes a summary f or each entry, we highly recommend reading the full article f or programs you are interested in as we go into much greater detail in the individual reviews.
If you want to read about what sets these new 11th Gen CPUs apart from the previous generation, we recommend checking out our landing page f or the 11th Gen Intel C or e Process or s.
Labs Open Office Hour: Labs Lads Discuss the New 11th Gen Intel C or e CPU Launch
While specifications are often not that useful when comparing Intel and AMD CPUs ( or even two CPUs from different families), we did want to specifically point out the MSRP pricing f or the 11th Gen CPUs as compared to the previous 10th Gen CPUs and the AMD Ryzen 5000 series. While pricing currently fluctuates widely depending on supply, this is still imp or tant because it gives a baseline with which to compare the different CPUs.
Process or | MSRP |
Intel C or e i5 10600K 6 C or e | $262 |
Intel C or e i5 11600K 6 C or e | $262 |
AMD Ryzen 5 5600X 6 C or e | $299 |
Intel C or e i7 10700K 8 C or e | $374 |
Intel C or e i7 11700K 8 C or e | $399 |
AMD Ryzen 7 5800X 8 C or e | $449 |
Intel C or e i9 10900K 10 C or e | $488 |
Intel C or e i9 11900K 8 C or e | $513 |
AMD Ryzen 9 5900X 12 C or e | $549 |
AMD Ryzen 9 5950X 16 C or e | $799 |
Content Creation W or kstations
Puget Systems offers a range of powerful and reliable systems that are tail or -made f or your unique w or kflow.
Labs Consultation Service
Our Labs team is available to provide in-depth hardware recommendations based on your w or kflow.
Read the full article: Adobe Photoshop: 11th Gen Intel C or e vs AMD Ryzen 5000 Series
Summary: Depending on your budget, the new 11th Gen Intel C or e process or s range from being essentially on par, to slightly behind AMD's current Ryzen offerings. At the i5 and i7 level, the C or e i5 11600K and C or e i7 11700K perf or m a bit under the Ryzen 5600X and 5800X respectively, but cost a bit less as well. The C or e i9 11900K, on the other hand, perf or ms about the same as the C or e i7 11700K, making it a both m or e expensive, and slower, than the Ryzen 5800X.
Overall, as long as you stick to the latest generation C or e i7/i5 or Ryzen 5/7 process or s, it is hard to go wrong with any of the Intel or AMD models f or Photoshop. Above that price range, however, there is little to gain from either brand. The Intel C or e i9 11900K isn't a great investment compared to the C or e i7 11700K, and Photoshop doesn't benefit from the higher c or e count of the AMD Ryzen 5900X and 5950X process or s. But below the ~$500 MSRP mark, you can pretty much expect to get a bit m or e perf or mance f or every bump up in price.
Read the full article: Adobe Lightroom Classic: 11th Gen Intel C or e vs AMD Ryzen 5000 Series
Summary: Unlike other applications like Photoshop where the 11th Gen CPUs often perf or m on par with the AMD Ryzen 5000 Series, AMD maintains a firm lead in Lightroom Classic. Depending on the price-point, the AMD Ryzen CPUs are overall 12% to 15% faster than the 11th Gen Intel CPUs, with most of that coming from passive tasks like exp or ting and generating previews where AMD can be 30% faster ( or m or e).
One saving grace f or Intel is that if you do not w or k with large numbers of photos, the Intel C or e i7 10700K and C or e i9 10900K are roughly on par with the AMD Ryzen process or s f or active tasks like switching between modules, adjustment sliders, etc. They are not faster than AMD, and even the Ryzen 5600X will perf or m within a few percent, but at least Intel is able to close the gap f or those types of tasks.
Overall, however, if you are looking f or a Lightroom Classic w or kstation, you will want to stick with the AMD Ryzen CPUs f or now.
Read the full article: Adobe After Effects: 11th Gen Intel C or e vs AMD Ryzen 5000 Series
Summary: Depending on your budget, the new 11th Gen Intel C or e process or s are either slightly faster or slightly slower than the AMD Ryzen CPUs depending on the type of w or kload. At the i5/i7 level, the C or e i5 11600K and C or e i7 11700K are a bit faster than the Ryzen 5600X and 5800X f or RAM Preview and Rendering but fall behind quite a bit f or Tracking tasks. The C or e i9 11900K, on the other hand, perf or ms about the same as the C or e i7 11700K, making it a relatively po or value compared to either the 11700K or a similarly priced AMD Ryzen process or .
Overall, we would recommend going with the Intel 11th Gen CPUs if you don't do a lot of tracking, or the AMD Ryzen 5000 series if you do. Intel's advantage f or RAM Preview and Rendering isn't that large, however, so if you are looking f or the most balanced option, AMD is likely the best option at the moment.
Read the full article: Adobe Premiere Pro: 11th Gen Intel C or e vs AMD Ryzen 5000 Series
Summary: Depending on your budget, the new 11th Gen Intel C or e process or s range from being slightly ahead, to slightly behind AMD's current Ryzen offerings. At the i5 and i7 level, the C or e i5 11600K and C or e i7 11700K cost a bit less than the Ryzen 5600X and 5800X respectively but perf or m within a handful of percent. This, with the advantage of supp or ting Quick Sync, puts Intel in a small lead.
The C or e i9 11900K, on the other hand, perf or ms about the same as the C or e i7 11700K, making it a bit m or e expensive and slower than the Ryzen 5800X, or 14% slower than the m or e expensive Ryzen 5900X.
Overall, we would say that Intel has a slight lead f or Premiere Pro at the sub-$400 range with the i5 11600K and i7 11700K, but the difference is so small that you could go with AMD if you wanted to without giving up too much. Above the $400 MSRP mark, however, AMD is likely going to be the better choice with their AMD Ryzen 5900X or 5950X.
Read the full article: DaVinci Resolve Studio: 11th Gen Intel C or e vs AMD Ryzen 5000 Series
Summary: Whether the new 11th Gen Intel C or e process or s are a good investment f or DaVinci Resolve depends on a number of fact or s including your budget and how imp or tant Fusion perf or mance is in your w or kflow.
Overall, we would rank the C or e i5 11600K as a better option over AMD if you are on a tight budget due to its higher Fusion perf or mance, while the C or e i7 11700K is roughly equal to the similarly priced options from AMD from a value standpoint. The C or e i9 11900K, however, you likely won't want to consider since, depending on the w or kload, it perf or ms either the same as the C or e i7 11700K, or is beaten by AMD's offerings.
Read the full article: Unreal Engine: 11th Gen Intel C or e vs AMD Ryzen 5000 Series
Summary: While Intel’s per-c or e perf or mance improvements do have noticeable impacts when compared to the 10th Gen, they still lag behind the Ryzen CPUs with the same c or e count or price. Only one Intel CPU managed to outperf or m an equal Ryzen CPU, but only in one specific test. Otherwise, AMD outperf or med Intel across the board, often at a lower price point.
Unreal Engine is an application that will leverage as many CPU c or es as you throw at it. As such, Intel only offers up to 8 c or es, while Ryzen also has 12 and 16 c or e options that significantly outperf or m anything Intel has. The Z590 platf or m also has improvements over the Z490, such as PCIe Gen4, but again, those improvements are putting them on par with what AMD has been offering f or a while.
Read the full article: Cinema 4D: 11th Gen Intel C or e vs AMD Ryzen 5000 Series
Summary: F or CPU based rendering, the number of c or es is the primary concern. Intel’s decision to cut two c or es from the i9 11900K really hurt it with this generation. It barely manages to match the perf or mance of the much less expensive AMD Ryzen 9 5800X. Only slightly m or e expensive than the 11900k is the 5900X which boasts 40% faster rendering perf or mance.
The lower tier 11700K and 11600k do show significant perf or mance improvements over the last generation but are just playing catchup with the similar offering from AMD. Then there is the upgrade path. If you did want to buy a w or kstation now, with the intent of upgrading the CPU later to improve rendering perf or mance, Intel’s top offering barely matches the middle of the pack from AMD. When it comes to CPU rendering, AMD is the only clear choice.
Read the full article: V-Ray: 11th Gen Intel C or e vs AMD Ryzen 5000 Series
Summary: F or CPU based rendering, the number of c or es is the primary concern. Intel’s decision to cut two c or es from the i9 11900K really hurt it with this generation. It barely manages to match the perf or mance of the much less expensive AMD Ryzen 9 5800X. Only slightly m or e expensive than the 11900k is the 5900X which boasts 40% faster rendering perf or mance.
The lower tier 11700K and 11600k do show significant perf or mance improvements over the last generation but are just playing catchup with the similar offering from AMD. Then there is the upgrade path. If you did want to buy a w or kstation now, with the intent of upgrading the CPU later to improve rendering perf or mance, Intel’s top offering barely matches the middle of the pack from AMD. When it comes to CPU rendering, AMD is the only clear choice.
Read the full article: Agisoft Metashape 1.7.2: 11th Gen Intel C or e vs AMD Ryzen 5000 Series
Summary: The new Intel 11th Gen C or e process or s perf or m near the top in our Agisoft Metashape benchmark. However, AMD's Ryzen 7 5800X beats them f or roughly the same price: its MSRP of $449 puts it right between the $399 and $513 f or Intel's C or e i7 11700K and i9 11900K, respectively. AMD's higher-end Ryzen 9 chips can also get a perf or mance boost in Metashape by disabling SMT, putting them even further ahead of Intel. Those wanting the absolute best perf or mance in Metashape will want to stick with AMD's Ryzen 5000 Series, but f or most users any of these top-end Intel and AMD process or s would do very nicely.
While the 11th Gen Intel C or e process or s showed terrific perf or mance gains versus the previous 10th Gen CPUs (especially at the i5 and i7 level), in many cases it is only enough to catch up to AMD's Ryzen 5000 series process or s. and in the case of the C or e i9 11900K, the loss of two c or es versus the C or e i9 10900K it replaces means that it rarely matches the AMD Ryzen 5900X or even the less expensive Ryzen 5800X outside a handful of specific tasks.
The C or e i5 11600K is likely the strongest CPU of this new line – often matching or slightly beating the slightly m or e expensive Ryzen 5600X. This is not true f or all w or kloads, however, so you should check our individual application results to ensure that you are not using an application (like Lightroom Classic) that perf or ms best with an AMD CPU. But in general, the i5 11600K is a great CPU if you are on a tight budget.
The C or e i7 11700K isn't quite as good as the C or e i5 11600K relative to AMD, but in many cases is roughly on par with the Ryzen 5800X as far as value goes since it is slightly slower, but also slightly less expensive. One of the biggest issues with the C or e i7 11700K is not that it under-perf or ms f or its price, but rather that it often perf or ms roughly the same as the C or e i9 11900K, making it on par with the highest-end SKU f or the Z490/Z590 platf or m. This leaves no upgrade path if you need a m or e powerful CPU in the future, while with the AMD Ryzen 5000 series, you can easily upgrade to the Ryzen 5900X/5950X, and presumably to the next generation of AMD Ryzen CPUs without too much trouble.
Overall, f or the 11th Gen Intel C or e CPUs, the C or e i5 11600K, in particular, is often a great option if you are on a tight budget, and the C or e i7 11700K can also be a solid choice depending on the w or kload. The C or e i9 11900K, on the other hand, is rarely w or th the investment over the 11700K and is typically significantly slower than the Ryzen 5900X which is only $36 m or e.
One thing we do want to note is that these results may change slightly in the coming weeks and months. We unf or tunately were not able to use a Z590 motherboard f or our testing, and while we don't expect that to affect the results, surprises can – and do – happen. In addition, there is a feature called "Thermal Velocity Boost" f or the C or e i9 11900K that is currently in beta that may allow that CPU to squeeze out a little bit m or e perf or mance. We don't expect either of these to greatly affect the results, but they may allow the C or e i9 11900K, in particular, to be a bit m or e competitive versus AMD. We should have follow-up articles covering both these topics in the near future.
If you are looking f or a w or kstation with one of these new 11th Gen Intel C or e CPUs, you can visit our solutions page to view our recommended w or kstations f or various software packages (some of which are using – or will be using – the 11th Gen CPUs), our custom configuration page, or contact one of our technology consultants f or help configuring a w or kstation that meets the specific needs of your unique w or kflow.
Intel C or e W or kstations
Puget Systems offers a range of powerful and reliable systems that are tail or -made f or your unique w or kflow.
Labs Consultation Service
Our Labs team is available to provide in-depth hardware recommendations based on your w or kflow.
Tags: After Effects, Cinebench, DaVinci Resolve, i5 11600K, i7 11700K, i9 11900K, Intel 11th Gen, Intel vs AMD, Lightroom CLassic, Metashape, Photoshop, Premiere Pro, Unreal Engine, V-Ray
بستن *به این
نظر امتیاز دهید
*نام و نام
خانوادگی * پست
الکترونیک * متن پیام
|
09226957293
.png)
.png)
.png)
.png)
(3).jpg?w=60)